Background: As a result of the various conflicts in the
region from 1947 to the present, from 200,00 - 400,000 Palestinian
refugees currently reside in Lebanon.. According to a 1998 UNRWA
report, there were 364,551 Palestinian refugees in Lebanon, the
majority in 12 refugee camps. Approximately 165,600 registered
refugees live outside camps in Lebanon. The above total number
of refugees would represent over 13% of the total Lebanese population.
These refugees have had major impacts on the Lebanese economy
and political balance. The re-settlement or assimilation of these
refugees is currently part of the diplomatic efforts concerning
the establishment of a Palestinian state, the Golan Heights issue
between Syria and Israel, Israeli security arrangements, and creation
of secure a Lebanese border. Lebanon is facing a negotiated settlement
of Palestinian refugees on its soil, as part of an agreement among
others, without representation at the table. Lebanese cannot forget
the destructive role played by the Palestinians during the war
(mainly between 1975 and 1982), and their actions designed to
establish a state within the Lebanese state. A repeat of this
history would pose serious threats to the two main achievements
of Lebanon in the Arab world: Democracy and Freedom.
Today the Lebanese have reached a consensus, rare in recent history,
in their rejection of this settlement because of the negative
impact on its very existence, and the historic balance that has
created the model of Christian-Muslim interaction in a pluralistic
society. The "settlement" of Palestinian refugees would
destroy the social and political equilibrium in Lebanon that has
been at the basis of its stability and democratic being
Economic Concerns: The ability of Lebanon in today's climate
to support itself is questionable. With a large national debt,
the ability of the government to cope with the basic infrastructure
and social issues of its own citizens has become tenuous at best,
even without the refugee problem. The outlook for economic recovery
is bleak. There is a shortage of jobs for professionals and a
crisis in educational institutions that turn out graduates with
no place to go. Naturalizing an additional 200,000-400,000 people
would compound these problems inordinately leading to economic
meltdown.
The settlement of refugees will worsen the already very high
demographic density in Lebanon, the highest in the Middle East.
This will aggravate the labor market at a time when tens of thousands
of young Lebanese are leaving their country every year because
of lack of jobs and business opportunity.
Political Balance: The political balance in Lebanon is
based on a confessional division. The division within the Palestinian
population would tip that balance marginalizing a major segment
of the Lebanese population. This may shatter the unique role Lebanon
has played in the region, as a true democracy comprised of multiple
minorities.
Retaining Palestinian refugees in Lebanon will sharpen their
feelings of deprivation and oppression and may be exploited by
radicals or other interested parties, to foment more violence,
worsen the security conditions inside their camps, and therefore
make these "ghettos" centers of terrorism and radicalism.
Discussion: Lebanon, as one of the authors and original
signatories of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights remains
committed to its principles. Lebanon supports the right of the
Palestinian refugees to return to their homeland in Palestine
or Israel as specified in UN General Assembly Resolution 194 (11
December 1948) which states that: "..refugees wishing to
return to their homes and live in peace with their neighbors should
be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date.."
The issue of Palestinian refugees in Lebanon is both an Arab and
international responsibility. Lebanon has provided a haven for
the Palestinians for many years at a tremendous economic, political,
social and human cost. The nation has suffered wars, economic
depression, and depletion of its youth through both emigration
and war casualties. Its economy is in shambles. Perpetuation of
this state will surely lead to total anarchy and the loss of democracy
in the only Arab world democracy remaining.
Desired Outcomes: Request the United States diplomatic
efforts:
Recognize Lebanon's unique position and ensure that the Palestinians
not be permanently settled in Lebanon.
Ensure that Lebanon is fully and effectively represented in
any negotiations regarding the fate of the Palestinians within
its borders.
Develop an equitable plan that fully recognizes the rights
of the Lebanese people as well as the rights of the Palestinians
to their own land in their own homeland.